5 Comments

User's avatar
Phil Williams's avatar

My favorite English-language King James edition of the Christian Bible is _The Skeptic's Annotated Bible_, with annotations by Steve Wells. The end matter contains over 450 examples of the book's contradictions, all carefully cited, along with 135 citations of God's killings in the Bible. Wells has also marked passages containing such flaws as absurdity, cringeworthy expressions of injustice, cruelty, violence, intolerance, misogyny, strange sex portrayals such as that between Lot and his two daughters, conflicts with science and history, and homophobia (though far less of the latter than modern-day fire-and-brimstone televangelists spew). Wells also marks passages that propound sounds ethics, or "good stuff," though that is heavily outweighed by boatloads of bad stuff.

More than a century ago, the pioneer French sociologist Emile Durkheim persuasively argued that religion is a construct of human societies and cannot be adequately analyzed outside of real-world societal contexts. To be sure, as a literary historian and critic, I would argue that the most prominent genre within the farrago of mostly odd components of the Bible is historical fiction (certainly not history)--along with prophecies by mostly God-intoxicated men, myths, poetic verse, prayers, genealogy, and a few other minor genres.

In more recent times, the skeptical magician James Randi offered something like a million dollars to anyone who could demonstrate in public that the paranormal or supernatural actually existed. All of the various paranormal con artists who tried to do so failed miserably in practice, and the prize unsurprisingly remain unclaimed during the rest of Randi's life.

Expand full comment
Karen Christensen's avatar

Quite a lot of what I had to say about translation got into this article in the Global Times, a Chinese newspaper published in English. https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202501/1326729.shtml

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts